Catholic School CompassTrue north for Catholic families.

Best value Catholic colleges in the Midwest

Catholic colleges in the Midwest with a Faith grade of B or better, ranked by the value index: net price, graduation rate, earnings and debt.

Best value Catholic colleges in the Midwest29 schools

29 schools qualify, ranked by value index. The top 25 are shown.

How this list is made

  • Catholic undergraduate colleges on the Compass. Seminaries and graduate-only schools are not counted.
  • Faith grade B or better (Faith score 70 or higher). Cost and outcomes never change a grade.
  • In the Midwest (U.S. Census Bureau region).
  • Has a value index from federal data (College Scorecard).
  • Each school needs a complete Compass Score, so every row shows a rating.
  • Ordered by value index, highest first.

Updated Oct. 12, 2026. Methodology. Spot an error? Send a correction.

  1. 1

    Saint Mary's University of Minnesota

    Winona, MN · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 72.0
    • Net price $11,704 a year
  2. 2

    University of Notre Dame

    Notre Dame, IN · Private nonprofitHonor Roll
    • Value index 71.9
    • Net price $26,780 a year
  3. 3

    University of Detroit Mercy

    Detroit, MI · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 71.6
    • Net price $15,232 a year
  4. 4

    Rockhurst University

    Kansas City, MO · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 65.7
    • Net price $25,884 a year
  5. 5

    University of Mary

    Bismarck, ND · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 63.9
    • Net price $17,770 a year
  6. 6

    Saint Louis University

    Saint Louis, MO · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 62.1
    • Net price $24,398 a year
  7. 7

    University of Dayton

    Dayton, OH · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 61.1
    • Net price $29,533 a year
  8. 8

    Marquette University

    Milwaukee, WI · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 60.5
    • Net price $31,487 a year
  9. 9

    University of St. Thomas

    Saint Paul, MN · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 60.4
    • Net price $29,155 a year
  10. 10

    Creighton University

    Omaha, NE · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 58.2
    • Net price $31,568 a year
  11. 10

    Saint Johns University

    Collegeville, MN · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 58.2
    • Net price $25,672 a year
  12. 12

    Loras College

    Dubuque, IA · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 56.3
    • Net price $20,716 a year
  13. 13

    College of Saint Benedict

    Saint Joseph, MN · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 55.5
    • Net price $26,640 a year
  14. 14

    Loyola University Chicago

    Chicago, IL · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 55.4
    • Net price $36,079 a year
  15. 15

    DePaul University

    Chicago, IL · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 55.1
    • Net price $30,902 a year
  16. 16

    Franciscan University of Steubenville

    Steubenville, OH · Private nonprofitHonor Roll
    • Value index 53.5
    • Net price $23,589 a year
  17. 16

    Xavier University

    Cincinnati, OH · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 53.5
    • Net price $32,997 a year
  18. 16

    Newman University

    Wichita, KS · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 53.5
    • Net price $19,971 a year
  19. 19

    Benedictine University

    Lisle, IL · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 52.0
    • Net price $22,313 a year
  20. 20

    University of Saint Francis-Fort Wayne

    Fort Wayne, IN · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 51.5
    • Net price $18,196 a year
  21. 20

    Walsh University

    North Canton, OH · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 51.5
    • Net price $20,493 a year
  22. 20

    Saint Norbert College

    De Pere, WI · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 51.5
    • Net price $26,172 a year
  23. 23

    Saint Mary's College

    Notre Dame, IN · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 51.0
    • Net price $25,292 a year
  24. 24

    Marian University

    Indianapolis, IN · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 50.7
    • Net price $24,018 a year
  25. 25

    Saint Ambrose University

    Davenport, IA · Private nonprofit
    • Value index 50.4
    • Net price $24,691 a year

Compare cost and outcomes

SchoolNet price a yearMedian debtEarnings 10 years outGraduation rate
Saint Mary's University of Minnesota$11,704$21,500$58,17066%
University of Notre Dame$26,780$19,000$99,98095%
University of Detroit Mercy$15,232$23,250$71,03067%
Rockhurst University$25,884$18,250$67,10275%
University of Mary$17,770$24,000$60,90967%
Saint Louis University$24,398$25,000$70,78380%
University of Dayton$29,533$23,250$75,53780%
Marquette University$31,487$23,940$78,25783%
University of St. Thomas$29,155$23,250$73,73976%
Creighton University$31,568$25,000$73,91183%
Saint Johns University$25,672$27,000$76,78675%
Loras College$20,716$26,000$58,28968%
College of Saint Benedict$26,640$26,944$63,26077%
Loyola University Chicago$36,079$24,157$71,53073%
DePaul University$30,902$23,168$68,75168%
Franciscan University of Steubenville$23,589$23,384$50,03075%
Xavier University$32,997$23,250$64,87369%
Newman University$19,971$20,801$55,04153%
Benedictine University$22,313$22,500$63,44650%
University of Saint Francis-Fort Wayne$18,196$25,976$55,36255%
Walsh University$20,493$27,000$59,76459%
Saint Norbert College$26,172$26,731$58,36371%
Saint Mary's College$25,292$27,000$59,35469%
Marian University$24,018$27,000$58,75967%
Saint Ambrose University$24,691$25,000$59,53161%

Net price is the average yearly cost after grants. Federal data (College Scorecard). “—” means the school reports no figure.

By state

All top school lists →