Most selective Catholic colleges in New York
Catholic colleges that admit the smallest share of applicants.
Most selective Catholic colleges in New York8 schools
8 schools qualify, ranked by admission rate.
How this list is made
- Schools in New York.
- Catholic undergraduate colleges on the Compass. Seminaries and graduate-only schools are not counted.
- Faith grade B or better (Faith score 70 or higher). Cost and outcomes never change a grade.
- Has an admission rate from federal data (College Scorecard). Average SAT scores are shown where the college reports them.
- Each school needs a complete Compass Score, so every row shows a rating.
- Ordered by admission rate, lowest first. Selectivity measures demand for places, not the quality of a school’s faith life.
Updated Oct. 8, 2026. Methodology. Spot an error? Send a correction.
- 1
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
Compare cost and outcomes
| School | Net price a year | Median debt | Earnings 10 years out | Graduation rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fordham University | $44,338 | $24,300 | $85,569 | 82% |
| Siena College | $33,733 | $26,561 | $76,079 | 75% |
| Canisius University | $17,940 | $24,250 | $60,681 | 66% |
| Manhattan University | $27,256 | $26,000 | $86,316 | 64% |
| St. Bonaventure University | $27,074 | $26,000 | $57,214 | 67% |
| Le Moyne College | $22,277 | $23,000 | $62,731 | 73% |
| St. John's University-New York | $29,999 | $25,000 | $69,571 | 66% |
| Niagara University | $17,248 | $25,475 | $56,196 | 75% |
Net price is the average yearly cost after grants. Federal data (College Scorecard). “—” means the school reports no figure.